Top 25 Albums ListThis fella decided to put together his top 25 albums of all time. I'm not sure if he was basing this on which albums affected his life the most, or which albums are socially considered the most influencial among Rock snobs. My opinion is it's the latter because if you look at where he mentions what he thinks the best songs are on each album, he doesn't really choose the deep cuts.
ANYWAY
I've read a lot of top 25, top 100, etc. lists of albums and this one, I think, comes closest to being correct. I don't really agree with his order. I think ording it is pretty subjective. As long as the albums are mentioned in the list, that's good enough for me. Rather than go down and say which ones I agree with, it's easier to say which ones I disagree with, why, and what I'd replace with. I'm basing this on how these albums affected my life and how I perceived they affected our culture during its heyday.
1. Replace, The Beatles' "Revolver," with The Beatles' "Help!": Gary argues this album is where the Beatles changed over from pop artists to revolutionaries. Nope. "Help!" was released a whole year before "Revolver." Look at the album right before "Help!," "Beatles VI." It featured pop songs like "Eight Days a Week." So with all the hype and craziness surrounding the Beatles and their US invasion, they weren't sleeping, not eating, just going mad. Then in '65, they release an album. You put the needle on the record and what's the first thing you hear? "HELP! I need somebody! HELP!..." This, my friend, is when the Beatles changed. At some point between Beatles VI and Help, they became friends with Bob Dylan. If you can't hear his influence on this album (Hide Your Love Away), you be deaf. This is the album that started them on the path toward masterpieces like Sgt Pepper and Abbey Road.
2. Replace, Led Zeppelin IV with Led Zeppelin I: LZ 4 is great. Top to bottom, it's complete and still stands up today. Does it belong in the top 25 based on my criteria? No. LZ 1 belongs in its place soley because when it was released in 1969, there was NOTHING like it. Could you imagine being a teenager and putting this record on with headphones, then the first track, "Good Times, Bad Times" comes on? I mean, what is your reaction to this in 1969? That is why LZ 1 belongs here over LZ 4.
3. Replace, Grateful Dead, "American Beauty," with Grateful Dead's, "Live Dead.": Everyone who knows me knows I'm a big Dead fan. American Beauty is probably their biggest studio album, sales-wise. I'm guessing that's why Gary put this in there. We Dead Heads know their magic didn't come from the studio, but from the stage. "Live Dead," is my favorite commercial Dead live album. Obviously there are bootlegs that destroy it, but you can't go to a CD store and buy a copy of the Dead playing Cornell University in 1977. So you can't put it on the list.
4. Replace, Crosby Stills Nash & Young's, "Deja Vu," with The Rolling Stones' "Hot Rocks.": Normally I'd say it's cheating to put a band's greatist hits CD on an all time best list to compete with another band's single work, but Gary left the Stones off his list entirely and I don't see how you can leave off one of the most important bands of our lifetime. The Stones were an odd egg. They have SO many great songs, but no single album really stands out. So I think in this case you have to make an exception and use this compilation album which contains almost all of their groundbreaking songs from '64-'71.
5. Replace, Radiohead's, "The Bends," with Guns N Roses' "Appetite For Destruction.": Gary already put "OK Computer," on his list. I think Radiohead was/is a significant band, so they deserve one album on here. Not two. Pink Floyd got two albums and Radiohead ain't no Pink Floyd. These two are their best albums, and if I had to put one on an all time list, "OK Computer" gets the nod over "The Bends." When GnR blasted on the scene in '87 (or 1988 if you didn't live in LA), they were the coolest mofos on the planet. They didn't act like rockstars to sell an image. That was them being them! There was no other profession for Axl or Slash. They were going to be playing music in a club on the Sunset Strip, or begging for change outside of one. It was either or. No in between. And "Appetite" is by far the most complete hard rock album of the '80s. Plus, if you were at a party here in 2007, and someone put this on, not one person would complain. Put "The Bends," on, and I guarantee someone says, "What is this?"
6. Replace, Jethro Tull's, "Aqualung," with ANYTHING!: Seriously. Who even puts Jethro Tull in their top 100 bands ever? That's like asking someone to name the top 25 movies of all time and putting "Throw Mamma From the Train," at #24. Some albums we can conider...
"Kind of Blue" Miles Davis
"1977" Talking Heads
"Velvet Underground" Velvet Underground
"Surfer Rosa" The Pixies
"Siamese Dream" Smashing Pumpkins
"Disraeli Gears" Cream
Others????